Realism in Adlof Menzel’s Art
1. Introduction
Adolf Menzel is a well-known German realist artist who was born in 1815 and died in 1905. “Realism in the arts is the attempt to represent subject matter truthfully, without artificiality and avoiding artistic conventions, implausible, exotic and supernatural elements.” Therefore, realism in arts is very important for every artist throughout history. Also, art historians pay more attention to realism and naturalism in arts because they can trace the social and cultural changes. As a result, many artists and art critics argue that Menzel’s paintings and illustrations are clearly defined as the true works of realism from the 19th century. However, relative to many other great artists, art historians have paid little attention to Menzel according to the existing studies. Therefore, the existing studies are inadequate to provide anyone insights into how Menzel created his works and insight into his paintings. However, there are a number of outstanding researches and publications on the life and works of Menzel. The aim of this research is not only to introduce Menzel and the definition of realism in arts but also to develop an understanding of realism in Menzel, such as the techniques and influences he employed to achieve his works. The purpose of this research is to appreciate Menzel’s realist artwork better. While he is largely forgotten today, Adolf Menzel was the most famous living artist in Germany in the late nineteenth-century. He received more official awards than anyone had before, and after his death, he was honored with a special funeral, an unprecedented recognition for an artist. Menzel was also an artist who achieved enormous critical, popular, and financial success, despite the fact that his art never particularly sought to flatter the political or military establishment, as state-commissioned art often does. He remained outside the artistic and cultural processes, maintaining a degree of independence and freedom, which were rare and became even more unusual as the next century progressed. Also, many people are very familiar with responses to his works, which often are filtered through his glowing international reputation and the way that his art was understood and presented at the time. Although Menzel was celebrated in his lifetime as a modern, cosmopolitan artist in the vanguard of history painting, for people in a later age and particularly after the Second World War, his art has often been understood by its immediacy and directness as a realist art. Also, the art of Menzel’s own time was dominated by an academic hierarchy that esteemed, in an ascending order of superiority, history painting, portraiture, and landscape art. As a result of this, Menzel and other realist artists were marginalized within their contemporary cultural and artistic landscape, dismissed as mere painters of modern life, that is, people of little skill or message.
1.1 Background of Adlof Menzel
To understand how Adolf Menzel became a realist artist during the 1800s in Germany, it is important to identify his life history. Adolf Menzel was born December 8, 1815, in Bohemia, but his family moved to Berlin in 1816, which was where he continued to live until his death in 1905. His father, however, died in 1830, leaving Menzel to become the breadwinner for the family. As a result, from 1830, Menzel worked in the lithography workshop of his stepsister’s husband, becoming a skilled draftsman. He worked on several government commissions, including portraying the First Silesian War fought in 1740, which helped elevate him in the art world. But it is argued that the real turning point for Menzel’s realistic art career came in 1867, when, at the age of 52, he was appointed professor at the Prussian Academy of Arts in Berlin. This job not only signaled his official recognition as a talented painter, but also allowed him to experiment further with his realistic and detailed style, as he was able to produce illustrations, portraits, scenes of tradition and contemporary life as well as monumental decorative works for public buildings. It was also around this point that Menzel met Adolph Friedrich Erdmann von Menzel, who allowed him access to the private Greifswald Gallery. The collection there included a large number of works by Durer, something which also proved to be particularly influential for Menzel’s realism art. By studying Durer and going to the original’s works for inspiration and in-depth analysis of his linework, shadings and form, he found a new lease of energy in this innovative and realistic interpretation of the world. On the other hand, despite the benefits it could have for an up and coming artist, Menzel never took a trip to his new source of inspiration, the Northern coast of Germany, showing that perhaps Menzel, like his art, was very much focusing on his own immediate surroundings. This not only allowed him to produce truly lifelike and moving scenes from everyday life in Berlin, but also to bring a sense of national pride and identity in the face of the fans and fancies of incoming modernist styles from other countries. His work in the 1870s and 80s on monumental decorations and wartime scenes strive to portray the strong and rooted traditions of the “powerful Germany of the Kaiser,” and his thorough understanding of what elements made a piece of art harmonious and balanced, that he gained through his detailed studies of art of the past, allowed him to create striking and timeless pieces. Through a combination of historical context, the rigors of his successful career and personal connections to peers and the public, Menzel’s realism is placed into a clear light. As we will see in the essay, Menzel exploited the move away from romanticism and the increased popularity of realism in the later decades of the 19th century in the German art world. However, it is his careful and grounded study of the world around him and the traditions of the past, twined so cleverly with the new technologies and social changes of the time, that place him as one of the greatest realist artists of the 1800s. His ability to combine bitter truth about the world with the emotional and fanciful elements of being human allow his works to be both historically important and transcendently enjoyable to all those that see them. By finding out more of Menzel’s life, therefore, we can truly start to see how some of the most iconic Christmas and historical scenes of the 1800s were constructed and completed with such skill and tenacity.
1.2 Definition of Realism in Art
In art, “realism” refers to the attempt to represent subject matter truthfully, without artificiality and avoiding artistic conventions, implausible, exotic and supernatural elements. Realism has been prevalent in the arts at many periods, and it is in large part a matter of technique and training, and the avoidance of stylization. There are many different visual styles and mannerisms that have been called “realist”, for example all of which suggest the range of meanings the term has, and how it is bound up with taste, and also politics. The word “realism” is problematic when applied to the arts, and this leads to a wider problem as to the definitional elements of “realism” itself. There are certain fields where the use of the term “realist” justifiably describes an artist or work in terms of the content within it. For example, some social realists such as Honoré Daumier and Thomas Anshutz defined their work as agents of change and instruments of public awareness. However, in relation to the art of Menzel, it is the devices and techniques used to depict the content rather than the content itself that define his work as realistic. Menzel’s hyper-focus on detail, illumination and shadowing, and preference for working from life and direct observations come together to suggest an approach to rendering the world that feels both accurate and, in its prioritization of the casual and mundane, inherently critical of the mythological and historical subjects that dominate the ‘high’ art of the time. This is where “realism” in Menzel’s art can become both complex and fascinating and much stronger compared to mainstream art history parameters like the avoidance of artificiality and the unmasking of social constructions; where Menzel’s truthful representation of the ‘human scene’ in works like “The Balcony Room” is iconoclastic in its preference for depicting real life over ideal plein-air leisure. Adolf Menzel’s northern European realist contemporaries included the likes of Gustave Courbet and Honoré Daumier, known for his satirical print work, and today Menzel is often described as the preeminent German artist of the 19th century. His work covers a great range of styles, from portraiture to detailed architectural studies, and was often regarded as controversial in its prioritization of the ordinary over the fantastic or historic. Museums and galleries dedicated to his work note that he was widely heralded as a ground-breaking and unique talent, being honored with exhibitions during his lifetime and being made a ‘royal professor’ at the age of 40. His notoriety and success cannot be understated; but as art history has canonized the classical and the abstract, Menzel’s work has somewhat departed from mainstream artistic narrative and instead exists as a treasure trove of response to questions about truth and human experience, and also as a way of analyzing the value of ‘everyday scenes’ in the visual art.
1.3 Purpose of the Research
The main goal of the research concluded in this article is therefore to investigate how Menzel achieved realism and to explore the techniques he used. Additionally, the research aims to put Menzel’s realism into context and to understand why he painted in this way. Understanding Menzel’s use of realism will be important for a number of reasons. Firstly, by studying a particular artist or artwork, art historians are able to place that work into context. By understanding the way that Menzel created realism, historians will be able to develop a better understanding of the way Menzel depicted the world. Secondly, influence of light and shadow and how contemporary artists have adopted Menzel’s techniques. Through exploring the processes and tools that Menzel used in his quest for realism, the research can also shed light on the importance of technique and material in creating realistic effects. For example, throughout the process of analyzing his work, the documented use of emerging technologies in industrial Berlin has helped historians to understand Menzel’s engagement with the changing urban environment. Finally, the patterns of realism that are found in Menzel’s work help historians to place him in the wider tradition of realist art. Through studying in detail his approach, how the meaning of realism could have been manifested in different experiences and environments. The techniques and requirements of portraying a 19th century Berlin city scene, for example, may be different to representing the open countryside of a rural estate. By understanding what Menzel defined as realism and his reasons for painting in that way, the full scope of his contribution to this artistic mode can be appreciated.
2. Adlof Menzel’s Realism Techniques
By focusing on scenes of contemporary life, like “The Balcony Room”, Menzel was able to subvert authority and challenge traditional conventions of artistic subjects, such as historical or religious themes. He would often select moments of action or crisis, and employ cinematic techniques of viewpoint and focus in order to better highlight the characters and narrative points of his works.
For example, the light that streams in from the right of “Studio Wall” illuminates the array of painting and photography apparatus from a darkened background, which indicates not just the artist’s tools but the overall visual environment that the artist experiences. His attention to detail is well-documented, and Menzel would often make numerous sketches and study paintings before embarking on an oil painting. In order to create a specific effect, Menzel would carefully construct and balance his images so that there would be a natural progression and fluidity in conveying his intended narrative or focus. This combined with attention to detail, such as the recreation of every pore and hair in the many self-portraits he executed over his life, truly elevates his pieces from a composition of lines and pigment to engaging spectacles within his audience’s eyes.
Realistic art involves representing reality as it is – without any interpretation or distortion. In order to achieve this, Menzel would often create intricate layers of shadow and light within his work. His use of hatching and cross-hatching – forms of closely drawn parallel lines – allowed for a smooth spread of shadow, and the thick coating of paint which Menzel would build up in the final works would contribute to the luminescent quality of his representation of natural light. By manipulating light and dark so extensively, the context of the physical environment changes within his work, drawing focus to the people and events depicted.
Adolph Menzel’s work is characterized by an extreme level of detail and complexity, especially in his later works. Menzel was fascinated by new technologies and would often employ a grid system to create his large works, such as “The Iron Rolling Mill” of 1875. This technique involved dividing the original design into a grid and then recreating each square onto a large canvas, thus preserving the scale.
2.1 Use of Light and Shadow
Menzel used light and shadow to create a dramatic atmosphere in his work. For example, in “The Iron-Rolling Mill” painting, the bright light from the iron pouring in the image contrasts the surrounding dark environment, making the flowing liquid the focal point of the piece and its glow almost palpable. The workers, some of whom only their silhouette could be seen, are immersed in the shadow and contrast. Through the use of high contrast and dramatic shadow, he puts the focus on the vivid and powerful nature of heavy industry, hence emphasizing the human’s inventiveness and ambition under the hard and dangerous working conditions. On the other hand, in the “Studio Wall” painting in which Menzel depicted the equipment and figurines on the shelves in his own working studio, there seems to be a complete absence of dramatic shadow and the mood throughout the piece is consistent and light-hearted. One possible explanation for that could be the fact that Menzel was simply inspired by the casual and soothing morning light that was enjoyed within the studio at the time. The artist adopted a method of his own regarding the manipulation of light and shadow. In “Weekday in Paris” and “The Balcony Room”, Menzel used light and shadow in a more subtle manner. He painted light French scene very thinly in layers to create a shimmering effect of light, while the shadow is almost harmonized into just another tone and shades of the picture. Yet, in “The Balcony Room” Menzel introduced varying intensity of light via a wide dynamic range of value between the lit-up outer balcony and the central living room scene which is subtly illuminated by the outdoor light. This creates a strong sense of depth and 3D geometry, indicated by the shadow falling on the floor and the bright sunny view outside. These evidences demonstrate Menzel’s innovative and skillful use of light and shadow in generating dramatic focus, creating atmospheric effect and intriguing the viewers in a variety of ways in different pieces of work, no matter in a heavy industrial, dawn of life circumstance or calm and harmonious domestic environment. His ability to pay attention to detail and precision in manipulating light and shadow is commendable and Menzel had convincingly utilized this particular technique to expose elements of truth in life in accordance with the social realism movements. This marks the beginning of Menzel’s foray into the world of realism, as he produced more and more truthful representations of life using realist techniques in his works in the later stage of his artist career. His achievement in the art world is evident in the fact that artists before him imitated his style and technique, and critics at his time and modern days regard him as the most influential German realist artist in the 19th century.
2.2 Attention to Detail
In contrast to the general technique of depicting a subject in realism art, taking detailed attention to this subject’s surface and the effect’s light or reflections can bring the subject to visual realistic. Menzel’s art works also reflect this technique. In Menzel’s 1852 work, “The French Window at Nice”, he took great care in painting the rough surface of the stone wall, the rough texture of the foliage and smooth silk material on the dress. When we look at the stone wall in the painting, we can even see the highlighted scratched marks on the wall. This technique of paying extraordinary attention to every fine detail of the subject is no doubt time consuming. Nevertheless, if the artist can really put enough detail to an artwork in every aspect, then the end result of this artwork will be more close to reality and the detail of the work will definitely stand out. Another Menzel’s work “The Berlin-Potsdam Railway” of 1847 has a great example of detail attentiveness. If we take a good look at the brush work of this picture and using a magnifying glass, the every objects in the picture are painted stroke by stroke and yet very neat and the details are amazing, from the pillar on the left hand side, the track, the brick work on the floor and even the small wood holding the electric conducting wire are well care. This is the particular Menzel’s realism artwork that back up the argument that he has been very extraordinary in taking attention to detail in his work. In the modern contemporary art, it has been a common practice that artists combine the realism and abstraction into one piece of artwork. Nevertheless, to be a good and successful realism artist, especially taking the challenge of visual realism, he must first understand every aspect of the subject itself and give a very detailed analysis on it. As it discussed above, taking good attention to detail is an important task to do when applying realism technique. Menzel’s art works do reflect this technique from time to time, especially it can be shown from the small details, such as painting objects stroke by stroke, in his major work. These further prove that Menzel is not only a good realist but also one of the best.
2.3 Portrayal of Everyday Life
Specifically, Menzel uses his realistic style of art to portray what everyday life was like for the middle and lower classes of 19th century Germany. By providing realistic depictions of working and living conditions, Menzel uses his art to make a statement about the social and economic struggles of the day. For example, in his widely acclaimed painting, “The Iron Rolling Mill,” Menzel provides a detailed and spatially deep depiction of workers in a factory. However, unlike many artists who simply glorified the Industrial Revolution by showing factories in pastoral scenes of beautiful landscapes, Menzel presents a more realistic and grim portrayal of working conditions by using dark and neutral colors to create a suffocating and grimy atmosphere in the factory. Similarly, in Menzel’s sketches, “Study of a Sitting Woman” and “Rear view of a Garbage Cart,” he uses meticulous detail to illustrate the poverty which occupied most of the everyday life for many people living in cities. By showing women that are not just rich or noble, but instead are doing an everyday activity like sitting and sewing, Menzel brings a sense of relatability and familiarity to the audience, hence helping to further the statement on socially relevant issues. Similarly, by capturing the reality of what a garbage collector would look like from behind, Menzel achieves intimacy and proximity to the everyday pedestrian, effectively tying his artwork closer to the fabric of society. These types of paintings and sketches accurately represented what life was like for the majority of people during that time and allowed Menzel to become a leading figure in the Realist movement in Germany.
3. Influences on Adlof Menzel’s Realism
It is quite clear that Menzel’s work was significantly influenced by the specific historical circumstances of his time. Menzel lived in a very dynamic period characterized by immense changes in the political and social sphere. In particular, Germany was experiencing rapid modernization as a consequence of the industrial revolution. Factories were being opened up, international trade was increasing, and urban centers were expanding. From the mid-19th century, the democratic forces started gaining momentum, and there were visible attempts to reorganize the German states into a single, unified nation. This process was completed in 1871. The unification of Germany brought with it a desire for the exploration of the German identity, and this demand was transplanted into the art, including Menzel’s work. Menzel’s connection with his contemporary period and the desire to depict the common life of the people is quite evident in his many drawings, paintings, and even etchings. For example, Menzel’s famous illustration “The Iron Rolling Mill” made in 1872, just a year after the unification, highlights the industrial and bustling life in Germany, celebrating the emerging modern era and the primary role of industrialization. This work has been viewed by scholars as a symbol of a new beginning for Germany and also a masterpiece of realist art that accurately reflects the social and political time it seeks to depict. Overall, the historical context provided Menzel with both a subject matter to explore and an impetus for his particular brand of realist art. His attention to detail and exactness in portraying people and objects can be said to be a response to the growing importance of realism in the visual culture of the time. This is why Menzel is often lauded as the first modern German artist who had the vision to significantly deviate from the classical art that was prevalent at that time.
3.1 Historical Context
While Menzel is often identified as a primarily realist artist, in that his art attempts to depict life as it is without glorification or interpretation, art is always produced within a broader context. In fact, the very “realities” that realists attempted to capture shifted and changed over time. Understanding the historical context is an essential part of understanding Menzel’s realism. Firstly, it is important to consider the broader historical context of the 19th century in which Menzel was working. This was a period of significant development and change in Germany; Menzel lived through major events such as the Napoleonic Wars, the 1848 Revolutions, the unification of Germany, and the Industrial Revolution. Each of these had a significant impact on the political, social, and economic contexts in which Menzel existed, as well as on the everyday lives of the people he sought to represent in his art. Secondly, there was significant change occurring within the art world at this time as well. The late 18th and 19th centuries saw the consistent rise of the art academy as the supreme institution of art; that is, the place where the definition of what art is and how one should go about producing it was determined. However, the late 18th and 19th centuries also saw the increasing rise of nationalism and the movements towards politically independent, unified states in Europe. This had a direct impact on the development of art as states and rulers sought means to establish a unique, nationalist identity; they often turned to promoting historically accurate and “honest” art that depicted the values, lives, and lives of the common people in that nation. This sort of “nationalist realism” was markedly twin-sided if the nationalists themselves – for typically it was only the powerful and wealthy who would favor a given nationalistic ideology – favored the given style. It is also worth noting that academics, the art-literature that was being published in support of it, and the general artistic events and trends were increasingly influenced by technological advancements. For example, the development and impact of printing, publishing, photography, and new technological advancements in paint and brush technology began to play an important role in determining the place and value of different styles, mediums, and genres of art. These new popular media, which allowed art to be reproduced and disseminated on a broad scale to people who never would have had access to an original piece, artfully influenced both the creation of the physical works themselves and the values that began to become associated with different styles of art. As such, they also began to shift the dynamics of artistic production in terms of what art was being produced and who the intended audience was. These different themes – the political, the technological, and the artistic – provide a model for understanding the broader historical and contextual significance of Menzel’s realism. The next step is to critically analyze the art of Menzel himself and see how these potential influences manifest in his technique or subject matter.
3.2 Influence of Photography
Technology has been a great force of change to the world of which art has not been spared. Photography was one of the technological advancements that were expected to mark the end of painting. This was more so as a result of the argument that painting was going to be made redundant given the precision and objectivity it was offering from a physical view of objects. There was therefore, not only the fear of obsolescence. That was going to militate the sustenance of the art but also the acceptance that it could inform the long standing principles and values. Pioneers of photography were quite particular in establishing a strong relationship between the art of capturing images and the scientific principles that were expected to either depart from or interrogate long established painting conventions. These conventions included the perspective, accuracy, use of light and most importantly the use of color as an element of expressing emotion. Photography was expected to invent new approaches in capturing the essential ideas of art and as such edging painting towards obsolescence. The pioneers were not only keen on demonstrating the empirical power of photography but also its ability to free the mind from the ‘tyranny of the observable’. Therefore the early proponents of photography had a mission, among other things, to ensure that it could provide alternative expressive media. Photography has generally been known as the process whereby images are produced by the action of light and that of related radiation on a sensitive material. This was definitely the belief in the 19th century and the physical expectations of scientific intervention on painting techniques and style. This was particularly a challenge to realist painters of this period and it forms the basis of understanding the two principle ways in which Menzel was affected by photography, that is, stylistically and thematically. First and most, it is almost certain that Menzel’s acceptance of photography was on the basis of the primacy of scientific principles in its development. He sought to understand the interaction between light and matter and how it was captured by a particular surface in the way photography demanded. This explains why Menzel’s paintings are known to pay sharp attention to the effects of light on the object, a classic photography technique. It can also be understood that Menzel, like other painters who embraced the new technology, was able to identify a new phenomenon in the intellectual discourses but also to exploit the tension that was being formed between what was perceived by the naked eye and what could be recorded by the camera. It has been suggested that Menzel knew about the work of one of the early photographers, Johann Baptist, who had depicted one of the scientists that had influenced Menzel’s research. The conception that photographs could capture almost anything including those moments and things that could easily escape the human eye was the same reason that led to the victimization of the social meaning of personal and subjective expression in art. Menzel’s decision on what to capture on a photograph among the nearly infinite alternative views basically meant that subjective expression of a particular thought was bound to overrule. This kind of tension was further exacerbated by the utility and immediacy of photographs.
3.3 Impact of Social Realism Movement
The social realism movement in Menzel’s time also had a profound impact on his style. The movement aimed to use visual art as a form of social and political protest, in order to draw attention to social injustice and to critique the status quo. This can be seen particularly in the way the movement treated the lower classes of German society, as many social realist artists sought to portray the everyday life of the proletariat in order to inspire sympathy and awareness in the middle and upper classes. Menzel’s most famous piece, “The Iron Rolling Mill” is regarded as an iconic work of social realism and a testament to the impact and significance of the movement in inspiring and influencing his style. This painting depicts a dimly lit foundry, with unrecognizable workers laboring at an industrial machine. The thick layers of paint and rough, aggressive brushwork express the exhausting and harsh conditions the workers are experiencing. The focus on the workers themselves, rather than on any signs of success or wealth, highlights the dignity Menzel saw in the labor of these workers, as well as the difficulties and struggles of industrialization in German society. The painting is also famous for its depiction of such unidealized, smoky and difficult industry – the movement sought to depict a grittier, less sanitized image of the reality of industrial life, and “The Iron Rolling Mill” is a perfect example of this vision lived out in Menzel’s work.
4. Significance and Legacy of Adlof Menzel’s Realism
The meaning and significance of Menzel’s realism
The artwork of Adolf Menzel in the mid-nineteenth century is characteristic of the improvement in precise, naturalistic, and detailed representations. Menzel was one of the artists who essentially set up this kind of art style, in contrast to well-known romantic and sentimental art styles that rose from the neo-classical era. From the text I saw in the Alte Nationalgalerie, Berlin, and the Neue Pinakothek, Munich, realist works depended on close perception of the natural world and were described by daring and impromptu brushwork that gave the appearance of a casual, natural, and unpolished surface. In commitment to this, Menzel’s artwork generally utilized rounded techniques and strategies with a simple and exact brushstroke to render material and nuanced finishes of his subject. This, along with the use of his innovative lighting strategies, which show the effects of close examination and comprehensive investigation of the natural scene, reveals to record a solitary, immobile moment. It is also significant that he is accepting the effects of the main widespread European movement in the nineteenth century, the impact of photography realizing quick changes on much of contemporary practice, and from the country’s numerous politically empowering years of social and realist changes which influence perceptions of people. I feel that as a ‘history painting’, Menzel’s art particularly plays into the possibility of making a record of a significant historical event, but through the use of everyday reality enabling an additional level of identification, particularly for the informed audiences of that period who might have readily seen the surrounding portrayal of ordinary people in gentle and familiar settings. Despite the fact that Menzel was never a dissident or a reformist in his attitude nor did he share any likeness to the later realists, it is certain that the moderate innovative changes from neo-classical and romantic power in the move to realist mode were overwhelming during that period.
4.1 Influence on Contemporary Artists
Discussions on Menzel’s realism are unfinished without the influence on today’s artists. This subject has not been broached in great detail, but it has been made clear that “the artists of our own time, responding to such essential tendency in his work, are among those who have drawn most from it.” Indeed, to gauge Menzel’s importance to the current era from the short extract provided in the book, perhaps it could be argued that Menzel’s “lengthy and dedicated study of the nature of perception, and how the logic of mental activity produces pictures,” hence such discovery made by him is considered as “pioneering.” This “pioneering” discovery, because of the “photographic nature of Menzel’s eye and hand,” along with the “radical sense of experimentation and restlessness of style” of his late works, it should be most relevant to the existing contemporary genre such as photorealism and super realism. It is suggested that the relationship between Menzel and modern hyperrealists, much like Richard Estes or Chuck Close, could be explored, underlining the conceptual richness of Menzel’s artistic practice, which may apply to art practices of our times. However, Menzel’s impact on contemporary art might not be plain to the average viewers. For example, in a New York Times issue of 1974, featuring a show at the 20th Century Fox Gallery of the works of Richard Estes and Malcolm Morley, it is rather emphasized that “both [Estes and Morley], one a fantasist and the other a realist, fed their blind in a world gone mad on – you guessed it – Adolf Menzel.” Such critics, albeit maybe rather unfair to Menzel, was clearly offered to reveal the ongoing tension that Menzel set up, by his success in establishing a clear methodology and philosophy of empirical practice, within every individual contemporary artist, who tends to be somewhat or another deviated away from his main idea. We often bracket Menzel as too much of a representational artist, but by looking at the way his artwork has indebted to today’s contemporary artists – from the first Abstract generation onwards and compared to the “traditional icons” of Old Masters. And he is seen as the bridge between two great traditions of German art – the Cranach remedy of longer Thaler and Durer. The end of such reflection is yet another proof for the significance of Menzel on the art of the 21st century. Thus the essay could further explore Menzel’s interaction with contemporary art.
4.2 Recognition and Awards
Menzel’s talent and commitment to his work did not go unnoticed by the authorities. Firstly, he was elected to various prestigious academic organizations and artistic bodies during his lifetime. In 1850 he was made a member of the Berlin Academy, and in 1861 he was appointed professor. He was also elected as a member of the Adlermle Academy in Stockholm. In addition to this, Menzel was awarded a number of titles and medals in recognition of his work. He was made a Knight of the Order of St. Michael in Bavaria and Saxony, and also received the Bavarian Maximilian Order for Science and Art. In recognition of his contribution to the new Imperial Order of the Hohenzollern in 1871, Menzel was appointed a Knight of the Order. The culmination of his career was marked by his appointment as a ‘Ruling Councillor’ in 1987. His achievements were notable, Germany’s highest civilian medal is named in Menzel’s honor, and medals used to honor artistic and scientific achievements are called Adolf Menzel Medals. He has been chosen as a symbol for the recognition and celebration of creativity and cultural achievement. These honors were not only a reflection of the outstanding nature of Menzel’s artwork, but also had a profound practical impact on his working life. As a member of the Berlin Academy he became involved in the acquisition of contemporary and old master prints for the print collection. Moreover, these roles and appointments meant that Menzel was in a position to exert influence and to act as a mediator between the world of official art and the public, a role which to a certain extent he embraced. Menzel’s awards have helped to create an enduring image of his art and legacy. These recognitions draw attention to the extraordinary nature of his creative output, his dedication to his work, and his ability to capture the world around him in a realistic and yet innovative way. Some of Menzel’s own works have received recognition in their own right. For example, some of his most famous paintings have been honored on postage stamps and Menzel’s masterpieces can now be enjoyed worldwide in a variety of forms and media. Such popular recognition reaffirms the enduring impact of his artwork. His most famous painting, “The Balcony Room” and “The Iron Rolling Mill” appeared in German stamps in 1993. Moreover, “The Flute Concert” was symbolized on Swedish stamps five years after he was elected as a member of the Adlermle Academy in Stockholm. Such awards continue to raise his public profile and his work still continues to inspire many younger artists today. On the other hand, modern scholarship runs the risk of neglecting Menzel’s reputation as one of Germany’s leading artists of the 19th century. His reputation for using unglamorous subjects and portraying realistic and sometimes laborious tasks may have been misunderstood in some quarters since it has worked to reinforce the positive reputation of his work only more recently.
4.3 Contributions to the Realist Movement
Menzel’s contributions to the realist movement were particularly significant because of the social and political context of the time. The realist movement grew in opposition to the dominant essay pro Romantic style, which emphasized dramatic, emotional scenes and idealized figures. Realism was a way for artists to portray the world as it really was, complete with all its flaws and complexities. Menzel’s work became symbolic of the power of realism as a whole in the art world, and he was upheld as an example of the merit of realist work. In particular, for many scholars, Menzel’s illustrations of the lives of the working class in Berlin were the epitome of what realist art should be: a true reflection of the lives and societies of ordinary people. In light of these viewed contributions, many art historians have even been known to refer to the movement in Germany in Menzel’s time specifically as “Menzelian realist”. His work was also influential for the later rise of social realist movements in art. Social realist artists sought to use their work as a way of making political or social statements, and Menzel’s focus on the ordinary lives of the non-elite, as well as his attention to detailed depictions of social and industrial development, were seen as a precursor to the social realist movement in the early 20th century. His 1869 “The Iron Rolling Mill” (“Das Eisenwalzwerk”) was of particular importance, owing both to the mastery it showed in depicting the intensity and dynamism of industrial machinery, and also to the provocative claim it made in giving artistic recognition to the workers and the fruits of their effort, barely featuring any kind of ownership or high-class supervisory officer in any form. The potential for even minor workers and underclasses to be the sole focus of an important artistic work would have been seen as deeply contentious in an era when the majesty of the powerful and the sweeping beauty of the wealthy were the more accepted subjects. His success is a testament to his undeniable technical ability and the power of art to ignite real social change. His legacy in shaping the realist movement can still be seen today. For example, “The Iron Rolling Mill” inspired the renowned playwright Bertolt Brecht, who saw the inspiring and authentic world Menzel had created. Menzel’s constant sittings for his many monarchs, including King William I and his son, Crown Prince Frederick William, arguably signify his relation to the German Empire and the increasingly authoritative and influential Prussian state. That the intention and the aim of such a realistic depiction remained the subject of high and speculative intellectual debate for years and the engagement with the wider political ramifications that led Menzel to be seen as the ultimate realist in the German Empire, and that same fascination with the political statements of art helps to ensure that his work is still remembered and revered today.

Published by
Ace Tutors
View all posts