In social and legal debates, there is controversy over whether persons with diagnosable mental disorders should be held accountable for the crimes they commit. See brief background article: https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/about-fathers…Links to an external site.
Recently, we have seen an increased frequency of incidents where an individual kills or injures multiple innocent individuals, such as a high school in Parkland, Florida; a Walmart in El Paso, a synagogue in Pittsburgh, massage parlors in Atlanta, and a primary school in Uvalde TX (there are likely others as we speak). At times, the mental health status of the perpetrator is reported as the cause of the incident. In this context, answer the following questions:
Are individuals with confirmed mental disorders responsible for the crimes they commit? What should be done with purportedly “mentally ill” individuals who perpetrate serious crimes (when others are severely hurt or killed)? I need help writing my essay – research paper share your perspective and reasoning.
+++++
The issue of responsibility for crimes committed by individuals with diagnosed mental disorders is a complex one. Generally, people with mental health conditions should be held responsible for their actions, just as anyone else would be. However, their mental state at the time of the offense and the extent to which it affected their ability to understand the consequences of their actions may be considered during legal proceedings.
It’s important to note that not all mental disorders automatically render someone unable to understand the consequences of their actions or make them more prone to violent behavior. In fact, research suggests that people with mental illnesses are no more likely to commit violent crimes than those without mental illnesses. In most cases, individuals with mental illnesses are more likely to be the victims of violent crime than the perpetrators.
When an individual with a mental disorder commits a serious crime, it is essential to evaluate their mental state at the time of the offense and determine whether they were legally responsible for their actions. If they are deemed responsible, they should face the appropriate legal consequences.
In terms of what should be done with individuals who commit serious crimes while purportedly mentally ill, there is no single solution. In some cases, treatment for their mental illness may be appropriate, but this should not preclude them from facing legal consequences for their actions. In other cases, depending on the severity of the crime, imprisonment may be the appropriate course of action.
It’s worth noting that even if an individual is not deemed legally responsible for their actions due to mental illness, they may still receive psychiatric treatment or other interventions to prevent them from harming themselves or others in the future. Ultimately, each case must be evaluated on its own merits, taking into account the individual’s mental health status, the severity of the crime, and other relevant factors.
